Contact Us

Instructions

Frequently Asked Questions

ETD Help

Policies and Procedures

Copyright and Patents

Access Restrictions

Search ETDs:
Advanced Search
Browse by:
Browse ProQuest
Search ProQuest

Laney Graduate School

Rollins School of Public Health

Candler School of Theology

Emory College

Emory Libraries

New ETD website is now LIVE and located here: etd.library.emory.edu

The Fact of the Person of Jesus Christ: Dietrich Bonhoeffer's Act and Being

DeJonge, Michael Paul (2009)
Dissertation (246 pages)
Committee Chair / Thesis Adviser: Pacini, David S
Committee Members: Holifield, Brooks ; Makkreel, Rudolf A ; Strom, Jonathan
Research Fields: Theology; Philosophy
Keywords: Bonhoeffer, Dietrich; Barth, Karl; Holl, Karl; Luther, Martin; revelation
Program: Laney Graduate School, Religion
Permanent url: http://pid.emory.edu/ark:/25593/1dsr8

Abstract

This dissertation interprets the German theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer's (1906-1945) post-doctoral dissertation, Act and Being. I argue that it operates in the intellectual space cleared by Karl Barth, who places at the center of theological discussion the problem of transcendence, which says that the constructive, productive, and projective functions of human epistemological faculties make knowledge of a transcendent God impossible. In light of this problem, which reduces God and revelation to objects at human disposal, Barth argues that theology's conceptual basis must be a concept of contingent revelation. Barth articulates this contingency by treating revelation as the free 'act' of the God who is transcendent subject rather than object.

Bonhoeffer learns from Barth that the problem of transcendence requires theology to operate with a concept of contingent revelation, but Bonhoeffer finds Barth's understanding of contingency inadequate, since an act-concept of revelation cannot account for any continuous connection between the acting God and the human historical world. Bonhoeffer offers an alternative account of contingent revelation in the concept of 'person.' God is neither object nor subject but person, a historical being who acts. Only on this conceptual basis can theology maintain both the contingency and continuity of revelation.

Although the argument of Act and Being proceeds largely in philosophical terms, it is as its core a Lutheran theological argument. Barth's actualism, as Bonhoeffer puts it elsewhere, is a "Reformed actualism," reinterpreting in light of the problem of transcendence a traditional, Reformed or Calvinist understanding of revelation as the act or word of a sovereign God. Against this, Bonhoeffer develops the Lutheran understanding of revelation as the person of Jesus Christ. In the incarnation, God so fully enters the world that God acts out of historical being.

From Bonhoeffer's perspective, the superiority of the Lutheran person-concept of revelation, reflecting both the contingency and continuity of revelation, rests in its ability to fund a theology oriented to both the word and the world. It provides the leverage, therefore, to correct pre-Barthian theology's neglect of transcendence without bargaining away, as Bonhoeffer fears Barth does, attention to the historical world.

Table of Contents

Between Berlin and Barth

A theological impasse
The person-concept of revelation

The Problem of Act and Being

'Act' and 'being'
Philosophy and the problem of act and being

The problem of act and being defined
Act-philosophy

Transcendental philosophy
Idealism

Being-philosophy

Phenomenology
Genuine ontology

Part A and the argument of Act and Being

Theological criticism of philosophy
Philosophy and the argument of Act and Being

Barth's Reformed Actualism

Barth's act-theology

Bonhoeffer's presentation of Barth's act-theology
Barth's act-theology and the issue of dialectic
The Feuerbach problem and the elements of a solution

Barth's Reformed actualism

The subjective God's act of revelation
The indirect communication of revelation
Trinity
Incarnation and indirect communication
Confessional polemics and the person of Christ

Bonhoeffer's Lutheran Person-theology

Critical christology and Chalcedon

From an objective to a factual christology
From 'How?' to 'Who?'
From natures to person

Protestant christology: the present person of Christ
Person, union, and the concept of revelation
Hermeneutical christology

Bonhoeffer's Criticism of Barth

Discontinuities and the problem of historical existence
Limits and the problem of transcendence
Limits and the concept of revelation

Bonhoeffer's Alternative to Barth

Life in the church
Concept of revelation
The problem of act and being

Revelation as person
Revelation, Christ, and the church
Anthropology
Epistemology

Lutheran Heideggerianism
Evaluating Bonhoeffer's alternative to Barth

Charles Marsh
Christiane Tietz

Bonhoeffer's Criticism of Being-Theology

Sin: being and thinking in Adam
Being-theology

Revelation as an object
Revelation as being per se
Revelation as a process of consciousness

Karl Holl's theology of conscience

Bonhoeffer's criticism of Holl
Marshaling Luther against the Luther Renaissance

Concrete Ethics

Discipleship
Ethics
Barth

Files

application/pdf Dissertation/Thesis 246 pages (1.3 MB) [Access copy of Dissertation/Thesis]
Permission granted by the author to include this thesis or dissertation in this repository. All rights reserved by the author. Please contact the author for information regarding the reproduction and use of this thesis or dissertation.